Exercise No. 3 -- Creating a Scenario
- Read Chapter 4 ("Understanding and Using IFs") in Exploring and Shaping International Futures for background
instructions
on creating a scenario
- In this scenario
you will cut in half government military expenditure over a 10 period
of ten years, and then keep it at that level for the next twenty
years. You will do this by shifting the government expenditure by
destination
multiplier (gdsm) from 1.0 to
.5 for military expenditures by the year 2010. The effect of
this change would be to cut in half a government's expenditure on the
military. If they had been spending 16% of all government
expenditures on the military, after the change was fully in effect they
would be spending only 8% on the military. Your task is the
create
this scenario and then examine some consequences. Specifically,
you
will look at the impact such a change could have on your country's
conventional power (CPOW),
your country's GDP per capita
ppp (GDPPPC), and your
country's life expectancy (LIFEXP).
- Open up the IF program.
- Open up "Scenario Analysis" and choose the "Guided
Scenario Analysis"
option and hit "Continue." Since you have already explored the
base case for your country in previous exercises, you can hit "Next" in
Step One. In Step 2 choose your country. In Step 3 just hit
"Next."
- In Step 4 expand "Governments/Socio Political Systems" by
clicking on the "+" next to it and choose "Fiscal Expenditures" and
click on "gdsm" ("government expenditures by destination multiplier").
Your country's name should already be highlighted so just hit
"enter" and choose military. Click the "Fully Customize " button
and in the" desired value" box change the "1" to a ".5". In the
"Years to Repeat" box put "10" and hit the interpolate button.
You have now gradually halved your
government's expenditures on the military over the period from 2000 to
2010.
- Now go back to the "Years to repeat or interpolate" box and
replace
the "10" with a "30." Hit the "Change/Repeat" button -- you
have
now kept that change in effect for the next 30 year.
- Hit the "Exit to Scenario Tree" button and then hit the "Ok"
button. Back in the Step 4 screen hit the "Next" button.
You will be asked to "save your scenario" and you should give a
name and save this scenario -- to your usb drive it possible.
- In the "year to which
the model will run" box
replace
"2025" with "2030." Hit the "Start Run" button and wait until the
model has finished calculating the changes that were introduced by your
government's level of military expenditures. This
can take some time, have patience -- you have asked the model to
recalculate values for all other variables in the model based on the
changes you just made in military expenditures. Hit the "click to continue" button when the "run successful box" comes up.
- In the Step 6 screen you can see some of the changes the model
predicts will happen if military expenditures are cut in half. In
the "select year" box you can select 2030, the last year for this
scenario, and compare the figures for the "base file," with no military
budget change, to those for the "run file," with a 50% cut in
the military budget. Now produce three particular bar charts
documenting these changes.
- Click on "Display," and then the "Self-Managed Flexible Display." In the "type name" box type "CPOW." Click on CPOW (Conventional
power) and choose your country.
This variable is labeled "CPOW(0)" and contains the data that
flow
from your changed military expenditures.
- Find the "Files
Available for Display" box and select "1 - IFsBase.run." Again hit CPOW and choose your
country. You have now brought up the "base
model" and used it to calculate your country's conventional power under
the old higher military expenditure rate. This variable is
labeled "CPOW(1)."
- Hit the "Go to
Display"
button. Hit the "Graph" button and choose "bar chart" to see the data on conventional
power under your scenario [the CPOW(0) column]
and under the base model [the CPOW(1)column].
Using the
skills you acquired in doing Exercise No. 2 produce a correctly
labeled bar graph of these data. If you go to "Display
Format" in the Display Menu you can then go to "Format Legends"
and customize the labels on your chart. Click on the
CPOW(working) and replace it with "50% cut in Military Budget" and hit
enter. Click on the CPOW(base) and replace it with "No Cut in
Military Budget." If labels appear in other columns just
click on them and replace them with a blank "space" and hit enter.
Your can label the "y" axis label by hitting the "Set Title"
option under the "Display Format" tab. When your bar graph
appears right click on it and hit the "Customization Dialog."
You can then enter a good title and subtitle, change the "numeric
precision" to an appropriate number of decimal places and choose the
"both" button under the "Display" option to have both a graph and a
table. Change the "Points" so that the bar graph only goes to the
year 2030. Change the "Axis" minimum and maximum values so that
the differences between the two cases (50% military budget cut vs. no
military budget cut) are highlighted. Your bar graph should end
up looking something like this:

- Save your bar graphs and analysis in a Word file.
Hit "Save" and "Export." Open up a Word file and past the graph into it. Go
back to the
IF "Graphical Display" window and "save" the graph again as a JPG file
and "export" it to your USB drive for later use in your country study.
When saving these JPG files for later use you might want to
change the "pixel" numbers from 1000 to 750 and from 732 to 549. This will produce a bar graph that can more easily "fit" into a web page. You have to click the "file" button and hit the "browse" tab and find your USB drive to save it there.
- Hit the "continue" button and go back and repeat the process for GDP per capita ppp (GDPPCP) and then repeat it
again for life expectancy (LIFEXP).
In total, you should have three bar graphs like these:


In your Word document under your CPOW graph write an
analysis
describing how your change in government military expenditures impacted
your country's level of conventional military power. Don't forget to
examine what happens
to the differences over time. Remember, by "interpolating" these
changes
over an initial 10 year period you cannot expect to see the full effect
of the changes until 2010. Try to explain why you think these
differences
exist between the two scenarios -- the "causal" connection. A
good analysis can be done in several paragraphs. Now do the same
for your GDP per capita graph and your Life Expectancy graph. In
total you have three
scenario
analyses to do for this exercise: the effect of halving your
country's military expenditures on conventional military power; the
effect of
halving your country's military expenditures on GDP per capita;
and the effect of halving your country's military expenditures on
life expectancy. Remember, your scenario involves halving your
country's government military expenditures from 2000 to 2010 and
keeping it at that
level through 2030. You are comparing the consequences of this
halving
to what would happen if military expenditures remained a constant % of
the government's total budget from
2000
to 2030. Include a concluding paragraph in which assess
whether or not you would recommend that your country actually cut the %
of the government's budget spent on military expenditures. Base
you assessment on changes you
have documented this halving would produce.